In Memoriam

By Ikeda Christmas Cookie standards, these sugar cookies are the OG. And, my mother, Akiko Ikeda, was the OG of our family. My mother passed away peacefully on December 30th in Wisconsin, after a long illness. The full obituary is here, and Dan Woog wrote a very nice reflection on her as part of a group of people who made notable contributions to our hometown.

For me, the Ikeda Christmas Cookies are a major dimension of my childhood connection to my mom. She taught me how to make these sugar cookies (and the Viennese crescents and rainbow wreaths, shown here), and every bit of my sense for how these cookies should be comes directly from her.

To begin with, the sugar cookies are rolled unbelievably thin. About a millimeter. Baked in a 400°F oven, they can turn from raw to burnt in seconds. They’re almost like baked potato chips, but made out of cookie dough. To facilitate the rolling (and re-rolling) without the dough becoming tough, my mom learned (from somewhere?) that the counter must be dusted not with flour, but with a mixture of flour and sugar.

Many of my cutters come from her collection, and she and I both have always loved little tiny cutters that can be used to get more cookies out of one rolling of dough.

The forbidden silvery balls

In my family there is a silly (but true!) story of a little glass vial of silvery sugar balls that my mother kept in her cookie decorating box for our entire lives, but which we were never allowed to use. These miniature, shiny jawbreakers were deemed too hard on the teeth, so despite being very pretty, were never actually put on anything. If any innocent friends happened to join in for the decorating and reached for the vial, they’d be promptly set straight. But, there the silvery balls lived, tantalizingly, in the box alongside other decorations. For decades. And, out of sheer sentimentality, that very vial now sits in my own cookie decorating box.

My mother liked to give us gifts that were “themed”. Music notes and bunny rabbits for me. Sailboats, labrador retrievers, and dragonflies for Jennifer. Ladybugs and cats for Louise. You can see these themes in the variety of cutters that I have now.

My mother would spend many hours making hundreds of cookies, candies, and fruitcakes every December, and she would assemble saran-wrapped paper plates laden with assortments, then send us around the neighborhood delivering them to family friends.

My mom was generous, loving, dedicated to working hard for others, and exquisitely exacting. She wouldn’t come out and tell me that I was doing something wrong, but she might instead take over a task from me if I wasn’t quite doing it right. It gave me pride when I became skilled enough to be able to share in more and more of the steps myself. Eventually, as her eyesight, dexterity, and energy declined, I took on the mantle for the cookie production in the family. As my first blog post explains, I’ve had to take years-long pauses from them, but every time I come back to making these cookies, I’m immediately at my mother’s elbow again, endeavoring to make cookies that would be mom-approved.

If you know me at all, you’ll recognize that striving for “mom-approved” isn’t limited to Christmas Cookies.

Christmas Cookies 2020 (made in January 2021)

The pandemic has afforded me the possibility of making the Ikeda Christmas Cookies two years in a row! Here are some thoughts:

  • I baked the Sugar Cookies without any kind of pan liner, using my very thin, metal spatulas. I suspect this is best for clean, even browning of these very thin cookies.
  • When making the Candy Cane Cookies, why do I always end up with more red dough than white dough? I’m reasonably sure there is some optical trick that makes me roll the red thinner than the white. You can see in the box of finished cookies where there’s a tiny red & white Candy Cane (blue arrow) and several all-red Candy Canes. I’m hoping that my new analytical balance will settle this matter next year!

Look at all these wonderful cutters that I’ve accumulated over the decades! Many are thoughtful gifts from kind friends and family members, and some are inherited from my mom. The Ikeda sisters worked on these cookies at mom’s elbow for many years as little kids, and after we finished baking we would deliver them around the neighborhood.

Finally: This was my attempt at making a coronavirus cookie… [sigh] And, this is a view of my Sugar Cookie workstation, offering a glimpse of my pandemic work environment and this year’s cookie-making binge-streaming fodder.

Christmas Cookies 2019 (after a long hiatus)

Being a teacher, which I have loved, is a profoundly exhausting and all-consuming profession. Not that working in bio-tech was a picnic, of course, but I have never felt as fulfilled or exhausted as I have as a teacher. On weekends and holidays – or even just at the end of each teaching day – I’d just sort-of collapse and need to let my mind and body recover.

This didn’t leave much energy or time for the significant production that is the Ikeda Christmas Cookie scene. But in 2019 the school calendar happened to play out in a way that resulted in a rare two-week Christmas vacation, allowing me time to recover and then to bake like crazy. It was wonderful to get back to it, and to find the muscle-memory still intact, and to introduce a little bit of innovation.

I now own enough silicone pan liners that I’m using them all the time. Unlike “air bake” pans, I think the silicone liners manage to avoid delaying browning – mostly. They definitely avoid sticking and are simpler than parchment, but I wonder if parchment would have been preferable for the sugar cookies, in terms of browning. With 2021 hindsight, and now that I own a box of pre-cut parchment, maybe I’ll opt for that this year?

In an attempt to make the cookies as uniform as possible, I tried using my food scale to help, but the masses involved were too small and exceeded this scale’s ability to cope. So, I bought a lab scale that is specifically for smaller masses (no more than 200g) and I can’t wait to use it for the next Christmas Cookie production.

Anyway, this gallery gives you an idea of the production that is involved. The Viennese Crescents trace back to a 1955 New York Times article that my mother must have discovered. They are, by my taste, the best tasting of the Ikeda Christmas Cookies, and also the easiest to make.

The Wreaths are my next favorite to eat, and though they are very time-consuming to make, I love working with the eggy, delicate dough. I don’t know the provenance of that recipe, but I do vividly recall my mom explaining that the sugar needed to be fine green sugar and chunkier red sugar – so that the red sugar would look like holly berries on the wreaths. This is but one of many aspects of the compulsive Ikeda tendencies surrounding this affair.

The Candy Canes, which are a recipe that didn’t come from mom (!) are, without question, the most time-consuming to create. I love their look more than their flavor, but I know some who prefer this cookie over the others. I once spent two hours preparing a tray of these at some ungodly hour of the morning only to then go and burn them. I cried, went to bed, then kept going the next day.

The secret to the sugar cookies, which I learned from mom, is to roll them excruciatingly thin, and this is aided by dusting the rolling surface with flour mixed with sugar. This keeps the dough from getting bogged down (toughened) with too much flour. The compulsive need to put eyes on every cutout shape that should have eyes is entirely my own mental illness. Can’t blame mom for that one!

[A keen eye might notice that one of the photos shows what I was streaming on the iPad while I was baking… ]